Ziauddin University has always played a leadership role in accepting and adapting best practices in the field of Education. Quality Enhancement Cell (QEC) of Ziauddin University has the commitment to ensure that educational provision of all the constituent institutions of the university are operating with the appropriate academic standard as provided by the respective accrediting bodies and are taking a deliberate step to bring about continual improvement in learning experiences of the student.
QEC has developed a culture which recognized the importance of quality and quality assurance in approval, monitoring and periodic review of academic Programmes. Assessment of students, quality assurance of teaching staff, learning resources, student support and information to the stakeholders. Review of the academic program is carried out by adopting consistency of procedures for the self- assessment system. Student course evaluation, teacher’s evaluation, graduating student survey, alumni survey and employee‘s survey are the important tools which are used for this purpose. An explicit follow-up procedure is in place to review the action taken by each program. In the latest quantitative assessment carried out by the Quality Assurance Agency of HEC in 2014, QEC of Ziauddin University obtained a score of 85% and was ranked in “W’ category.
As per HEC criteria, each academic program needs to undergo self-assessment every year. For the purpose of developing self-assessment procedures, QAA at HEC has initiated a process of establishing Quality Enhancement Cells at each university. These QECs are responsible for planning, coordinating and following up on the Self Assessment (SA) activities within their institutions. Each QEC is responsible for developing procedures for the following:
- Approval of new Programmes
- Annual monitoring and evaluations including program and faculty monitoring and student’s perception.
- Departmental review
- Student feedback
- Employer feedback
- Quality assurance of degree Programmes
- Subject review
- Institutional assessment
- Qualification framework
Ziauddin University has always been in the forefront for accepting and adapting best practices in the field of education. Recognizing the role that it has to play in higher education sector, Ziauddin University has established a Quality Enhancement Cell. This cell has the responsibility to ensure that the university’s quality assurance procedures are compatible with international standards and are designed to improve the quality of higher education.
Quality Enhancement Cell of Ziauddin University is mandated by Quality Assurance Agency of HEC to carry out an evaluation of its academic Programmes. This is carried out in the form of generation of Self Assessment Report (SAR) by the respective Programmes.
Following Programmes are selected and notifiedof the process of Self Assessment Report:
- BSc in Nursing
- MS in Emergency Medicine
First meeting with the program teams held. Guidance on writing Mission statements was provided. Members were facilitated for writing program objectives and Outcomes. The objectives of the Meeting were to:
- Discuss the mission statements of the Departments and Programmes.
- Facilitate in forming the Program objectives and strategic plans to achieve them.
- Introduce and circulate the different survey forms for Self Assessment.
- Discuss the outcomes of each program and its alignment with the objectives.
In addition to the QEC Director, Deputy director and ,Data Analyst following PT members attended the meeting:
First meeting with the program teams held. Guidance on writing Mission statements was provided. Members were facilitated for writing program objectives and Outcomes. The objectives of the Meeting were to:
- Ms. Shireen Arif
- Zehra Raheem
- MS in Emergency Medicine:
- Dr. Shua
- Dr. Adnan Shaikh
After a brief introduction about Quality Enhancement procedures laid down by QAA of HEC and its importance, the QEC team with the help of examples assisted the program teams in developing the Vision, Mission and Objectives of their program.
Each Program team discussed their Mission statements and received feedback from other participants and QEC team. This was followed by facilitation by the QEC team in developing the objectives and outcomes of their respective Programmes.
It was decided that meetings with the PTs will be held fortnightly as the Criterions and Standards are being completed step by step.
Notification for program evaluation of BS in Communication and Media Studies was made.
Weekly meetings with the PTs are held to expedite the report writing process. Evaluation proformas circulated, filled and submitted.
Nomination of Assessment Teams done.
Assessment Team visit at Ziauddin College of Nursing completed. Following were the external assessors:
- Mr. Hakima Shah, Director, Institute of Nursing, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi.
- Ms. Almas Chapsi, Principal, Institute of Nursing, National Medical Centre, Karachi.
A New phase of Self Assessment of academic Programmes started in Aug.2014.
On 13th Aug.2014 notification for initiating Self Assessment in the following Programmes was issued after approval of the VC:
- BS in Biomedical Engineering
- BS ( Radiology) in Allied Health Sciences
- MS in OBGYN
Members of Program teams for the above mentioned Programmes are:
- BS in Biomedical Engineering:
- Engr.M.Saqib Ejaz
- Dr.M.Fahad Shamim
- BS ( Radiology) in Allied Health Sciences:
- Ms. Mehwish Zeeshan
- Dr. Sarwat Faisal
- MS in OBGYN:
- Dr. Shazia Sultana
First Meeting Of Program Teams:
All the members of the three program teams were invited and briefed about the nuances of preparing Self Assessment Report. A presentation was made by the Director QEC and the team members were facilitated in writing Mission statements and objectives of their respective Programmes.
Second Meeting Of Program Teams:
In order to keep a follow up on the writing of Self Assessment Reports, a second meeting of the program teams was organized at Director’s QEC office. Members from all the teams attended the meeting and discussed about the problems they are facing in writing SARs. They were guided and all support was provided by the QEC in completing their tasks.
Ziauddin College of Physical Therapy in collaboration with the Quality Enhancement Cell of ZU organized a three days workshop titled “Faculty Professional Development” on 6th, 9th and 10th of June 2014. This workshop was aimed at helping the faculty members in improving their teaching, assessment and research skills. Ms Ms. Amna Khan, Associate Professor ZCPT guided the faculty in improving literature search andresearch writing skills. Dr. Arshia Samin Director QEC introduced the concept of Problem Based Learning, discussed the roles and responsibilities of different members of a PBL group and helped the faculty in developing Problem Based learning scenarios for Physical therapy Programmes. Last day of the workshop was dedicated to improving written assessment tools.
All the faculty members took the keen interest in the workshop and contributed actively to the discussions and deliberations. They appreciated such faculty development initiatives and requested for more teaching learning related workshops/ seminars in future. On the last day of the workshop certificates of participation were distributed among the faculty members.
Institutional Performance Evaluation (IPE) is of vital importance for all the DAIs that desire to meet the international standards. Higher Education Commission of Pakistan has developed eleven Institutional Performance Evaluation (IPE) Standards for a complete assessment of Degree Awarding Institutions (DAIs). To meet the medium term framework development targets for 2016-2020, all the DAIs are required to be evaluated against these standards.
The primary requirement for the evaluation of an institution is submission of University Portfolio Report which is to be prepared as per the IPE Manual provided by the HEC and submitted to HEC prior to the visit.
In order to get the mandatory IPE done, a very comprehensive Portfolio Report of Ziauddin University was prepared and submitted to HEC. The Institutional Performance Evaluation (IPE) visit was then scheduled by HEC from 11th to 13th April 2017and carried out by a three member inspection team.
The first day of the visit started with a meeting with of the team with the VC. The VC welcomed the members and gave a brief introduction of the university. The team members spent the rest of the day in checking all the documents placed on the tables as evidences for each standard.
Second day of the visit comprised of meeting of the inspection team members with the Registrar, Controller Examination, Deans/ Heads of the constituent colleges, select number of associate professors, assistant professors and lecturers. The team members also had a meeting with senior students from different academic Programmes of the university.
The team members visited different facilities of the university on the third day and ended their evaluation with an exit meeting with the VC.
The HEC team members highly appreciated the academic Programmes of ZU and stated that they were surprised with the level of satisfaction and motivation of faculty and students.
To complete the evaluation process a comprehensive evaluation report will be prepared by the HEC inspectors and shared with ZU in near future.
Training And Progress Review Meeting Of QEC’S 19th And 20th April, 2017 QAA, HEC At Islamabad:
HEC “Progress Review Meeting of QEC’s” and training on IPE visit and M.Phil/PhD program review visit was organized by Quality Assurance Agency (QAA), HEC at Margalla Hotel, Islamabad. The participants included Directors, Deputy Director, Assistant Director and Head of QEC’s from different universities of Pakistan.
Ms Zareen Hussain, Deputy Director QEC represented Ziauddin University in the meeting.
The meeting started at 9:30 a.m. with the recitation of Holy Quran and welcome statement by the Director General of QAA Prof. Dr Rafique Baloch. He discussed the purpose and importance of progress review meeting and training and how it can help QECs to meet QA standards and criteria.
On the first day all the QEC’s representatives gave presentations. Some highlights of the presentations were:
- Current standing of QEC in the institution that includes full time Permanent Staff, membership of Statutory Bodies and available resources.
- Analysis of last year’s performance as per scorecard of 2015-16 that included identification of weak areas.
- Steps taken for addressing those weak areas (implementation status and action plan).
- The hindrances in achieving the targets.
- Help required from HEC.
Each presentation was followed by questions answer session. After wards DG QAA presented the future scope and strategies to strengthen QECs in DAIs, which are as follows:
- QECs will be part of University Act
- Ranking/Scoring process will be revised
- SAR will be revised and there would be Peer Review instead of SA team.
- QAA will send reports to Vice Chancellors of all DAIs regarding importance and presence of Quality Enhancement cells in universities
- QAA will visit DAIs for M.Phil/PhD Programmes review
The meeting ended at 5:30 pm.
Day 2 began with the recitation of Holy Quran. Mr. Muhammad Shoaib, Project Director Quality Assurance Agency, conducted the training session on pre visit preparation for IPE. He discussed about University Portfolio (UPR) and all the eleven standards mentioned in IPE manual and required evidence against each question or standards. He described the approvals, policies, approval of policies and minutes of meetings are required as evidence. Also, notifications of certain things and its policy of distribution are also required. For better outcome QECs were suggested by QAA to perform IPE by itself before external IPE visit.
Moving forward, “Pre Visit Preparation for MS/M.Phil and PhD Program Review” was conducted by Mr. Shoaib Irshad. He discussed the issues, its measures and what should be done before HEC visit. He also emphasized on peer review process for MS/M.Phil and PhD Program. Further he discussed the criteria and importance of PhD review. Some important aspects were:
- HEC Approved Supervisor
- Program should be recognized by HEC
- Validation of academic program
- Acceptance of degrees
- Value Addition
Regarding the preparation of data as per requirement of review visit three types of proforma are required to be filled before review:
- Student Proforma
- Program Proforma
- Faculty Proforma
For each program these Proforma will be filled separately and certain documents would be required as evidence which included complete student files, PhD and non PhD faculty files.
Then steps of review process were discussed:
- QAA will send email to QECs to MS/M.Phil and PhD reviews and share Proforma (Program Proforma, student Proforma and faculty Proforma) to fill and send back to QAA before deadline.
- QAA will form a panel
- Size of panel and days of visits depends on the size of Student body or no. of Programmes
- After visit panelist prepare an initial report/first draft and submit it to QAA
- First draft will be shared with universities for review. If university found any refinement then send it back to QAA with valid proof within 1 week.
Afterwards mock visit conduction was also discussed and suggested that Vice chancellor should be involved in mock visit
Some important points are:
- One PhD faculty cannot supervise more than five PhD students.
- Adherence to HEC Criteria
- Load of Supervisor
- Student teacher ratio
- Involvement of senior faculty members
In the closing session, the DG QAA emphasized to arrange Mock IPE and MS/M.Phil and PhD visit before actual visit. The session ended with the distribution of certificates among participants by the DG QAA.
Introduction Of QEC To The New Entrants:
Ziauddin University has always strived to ensure the best standards of education, training, and research in its academic Programmes. Quality in education is a concern that requires the involvement of all the stakeholders. Student body being one of the important stakeholders needs to be informed of the Quality Assurance procedures being implied in the various Programmes of the university.
At Ziauddin University, new batches of MBBS and BDS Programmes were taken in during the month of November 2014. Two separate sessions on “Introduction of QEC” were organized for:
- MBBS program on 12th Nov. 2014
- BDS program on 27th Nov 2014
Dr. Arshia Samin, Director QEC conducted the sessions in which she gave the concept of quality and introduced the working of Quality Enhancement Cell at Ziauddin University. She motivated the students to take responsibility for their own learning by participating positively in all the quality assurance activities and described the various proformas that the students are expected to complete and are used as tools for program evaluation.
Visit Of QEC Director To SMBB Medical University, Larkana.
Dr. Arshia Samin, Director QEC Ziauddin University, in response to an invitation from the Registrar of Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto Medical University Larkana, conducted a one -day workshop on “Quality Assurance” on 8th Dec 2014, at their campus. The workshop was attended by a large number of senior faculty of the host university. The participants discussed the importance of quality assurance procedures in Higher Educational Institutions and they were facilitated to prepare a list of the various factors that determine the quality of a study program. The importance of the role of Quality Enhancement Cells in improving the quality of teaching/ learning Programmes was also discussed.
At the end, Dr. Arshia was presented with a momento of SMBB Medical University by Prof. Dr. Sikandar Ali Mughal, Registrar of the university and a gift of the traditional Sindhi shawl by the Principal of Chandka Medical College.
A NOVEL Initiative:
It’s always a general perception among the student community that their grievances are not given a heed. They think that their problems are not taken seriously and not conveyed to the higher authorities. In order to make the students actively participate in improving the quality of their educational program, QEC of Ziauddin University has installed a Complaint box on the outer wall of the QEC office. Students are free to put their complaints in the box. Weekly, the complaints are collected, reports are prepared and forwarded to the concerned department heads/ deans for further action. It has been a very useful initiative and students are finding it very helpful in conveying their problems.
Awareness Regarding Quality Assurance:
Following the tradition, this academic year i.e 2015 to 2016 started with the introduction of Quality Enhancement Cell and its activities to the new batches of students. The Director and Deputy Director QEC conducted awareness sessions for the students of various Programmes and informed them of the role that they can play in improving the quality of their learning Programmes.
Self Assessment In Academic Programmes Of Ziauddin University:
Ziauddin University has a commitment and associated procedures for the assurance of the quality and standards of its academic Programmes. Quality Enhancement Cell (QEC) of ZU has endeavored to develop a culture which recognizes the importance of quality in the entire educational environment. To achieve this, QEC follows the standards and guidelines for internal quality assurance provided by Quality Assurance Agency of HEC. Implementing a strategy for the continuous enhancement of quality, self assessment reports are prepared by the program teams of the various departments.
Since July 2015 QEC has successfully completed the SARs with the help of program teams of more than 20 Programmes including all the BS Programmes of Medical Technology, ADPT, PPDPT, MSN, BSN and a number of MS and MD Programmes.
Subject experts from other institutions of Karachi were invited as external assessors for reviewing the SARs and their critique and valuable input has been converted into action plans to be followed up in future.
Activities Related To Self Assessment Reports
First cycle of evaluation of academic Programmes according to the requirements of QAA of HEC has been completed. Second cycle of program evaluation has started with the following Programmes:
- BS in SL&HS
- BS in Clinical Lab Sciences
Members of the Program Teams nominated for the purpose are:
BS in Speech Language and Hearing Sciences
- Ms. Rabab Sehr
- Mr. Zafar Wafai
BS in Clinical Lab. Sciences
- Ms. Humera Rashid
- Ms. Qamarunnisa Naz
Doctor of Physical Therapy
- Mr. Mohammad Usman Khan
- Mr. Ali Farhad
Meetings with individual program teams for the Self Assessment report started in late December and continued till May 2017.
Report Of Training On “QUALITY ASSURANCE & GOVERNANCE” Funded By The Tertiary Education Support Program (TESP) Of HEC.
A training program on “Quality Assurance & Governance” was organized by the Institute of Management Sciences, Peshawar and funded by Tertiary Education Support Program. It was held from April 24 to April 26, 2017 at Hotel Mehran, Karachi.
Director QEC Dr Arshia was invited for the training session.
Participants of the training included representatives from both public and private sector DAIs and were mostly from the administrative or examination departments or from QECs.
Dr Azam Ali Khwaja was the resource person for the first day. He discussed about the changes in higher education administration that occurred in the wake of implementation of 18th Amendment in the country.
Second day session was facilitated by Dr Farmanullah. He discussed the quality assurance mechanisms that are provided by the QAA of HEC. He explained all the criteria of Self Assessment Reports and Institutional Performance Evaluation.
IT Training Stream for Quality assurance and Governance was the topic for the third day and was facilitated by Mr Imran Batada. He educated the participants regarding IT systems in Higher Education sector and gave a good overview of CMS, LMS and other IT systems. He also talked about Cloud computing and importance of Business Intelligence systems.
This three day program was a very informative and useful one. The best thing about the training program was facilitation by the experienced resource persons who very aptly provided glimpses of their personal experiences with different DAIs of Pakistan and abroad and kept the participants involved and active till late evening, each day.
Quality Assurance Agency of HEC assesses the progress of the Quality Enhancement Cells established in the public/ private sector universities through quantitative scorecard system.
QEC of Ziauddin University is proud to announce that as per the latest assessment for the period July 2013 to June 2014, we have scored 85% and are placed in the “W” category.
This is the third time in a row that we have been placed in the highest category and performance of QEC team has been highly appreciated by the Director General Quality Assurance Agency.